Managing Relationships with In-laws After a Divorce

bigstock_young_indian_couple_arguing_on_29804087

By Anjum Choudhry Nayyar

For most women, including mothers who have gone through a break up or divorce, the pain can be so hard to express.  There’s a feeling of rejection, trying to wrap your brain around what went wrong and how you could’ve kept your family together.   For me, watching my parents who had an arranged marriage go through many ups and downs and wondering as a child how they stayed together despite it all, made me aware of the fact that marriage is no fairytale. When kids are involved, sometimes they make you take paths that are for their well-being rather than your own.  It certainly makes a difference if through it all you have a strong family support network including with your in-laws.  Many friends of mine have been talking about the challenges they face with negative relationships with their in-laws or parents and they find striking that right balance between ‘keeping the peace for the kids sake’ and their own self-esteem.

This topic of in-laws and managing relationships can be so wrought with angst and lately I’ve been bombarded by stories from fellow moms. It has compelled me to write something and we’ll  be exploring the subject on a monthly basis because it’s such a large topic.  In our first on a series in this area, we talk to Nadia Shah (MSW),  who is  currently married and lives with her mother-in-law and brother-in-law.  “We take care of them financially. It’s a complete role reversal,” says Shah. She is also licensed as a clinical social worker (LCSW) and works full time as a clinical social worker for an Orange County mental health clinic. She has a great site on the subject called, www.southasianinlaws.com.  She talks to us about how a separation can affect your relationship with your in-laws and how we as moms can manage that.

After a divorce/separation, how can your relationship change with your in-laws, what challenges might a woman who’s a mother face? 

Naturally the relationship with in-laws will change once your divorced. A recently divorced mother will need to be prepared for a number of challenges. The main one will be trying to maintain a pleasant family environment for the child/children. There is a possibility that her in-laws or her ex will be saying negative things about her to the children and there is a possibility she may be expressing negative thoughts also. In addition to that, any divorcee needs to be aware that mixed feelings may arise when interacting with her ex or her in-laws. It’s natural to feel a variety of emotions when dropping the kids off at her ex’s or bumping into him somewhere else. Another challenge will be adjusting to a different family structure. Maybe the mother had support from her in-laws or was friends with her sister-in-law and hopefully she can continue some level of closeness with them but she should be prepared for change all around.

California mom, Vaishali also known as @ChaiChatter on twitter, recently talked about her experiences here.  She says, “The biggest challenge I’ve come across I separating myself from being their Bahoo to now being their grandkids’ mom. Although they’ve made a valiant effort to maintain a relationship with me , I’m the one that has separated the old from new hurt feelings have come about-but felt I needed to do that to disassociate myself from the past as much as I can given the circumstances in which I was divorced.”

If the relationship was a good one (with in-laws that is) how can that be maintained once a separation has occurred? what is important when it comes to open dialog and preventing resentment?

As we all know, we can only control our own actions therefore if you want to maintain the relationship, you have to be the one to put in extra effort. This means openly saying to your in-laws something along the lines of, “We have been family for X number of years and I would like to continue our relationship. I understand that there will be a lot of changes for all of us. What can I do to keep you a part of my life?” Don’t expect your in-laws to come to you and and put in the extra effort. They may be coming from a culture that practices indirect communication or be hesitant to approach you because they may think you want to disconnect. Make it clear what you want. Also to avoid resentment, I highly recommend not talking bad about your ex to your in-laws. Even if the whole divorce was your ex’s fault, you shouldn’t complain to your in-laws if you want to maintain a healthy relationship with them. They may already realize your ex (their family member) did something horrible, but no one wants to hear anything negative about their family members even if their family member is at fault.

If the relationship was a negative one prior to the breakup, should you try and continue to maintain a relationship with in-laws and how can this be done in spite of a breakup? how should children be encouraged to have that relationship with grandparents in this situation?

Unfortunately, many in-law relationships are unhealthy and negative, especially within our culture. In this situation, you still have the responsibility of maintaining at least a decent relationship with your in-laws for the benefit of your children. There is no such thing as “too much love” for kids so try to keep your in-laws involved in your kids’ lives. That might mean, calling them to invite them to birthday parties or sending your kids over to their house for holidays. You should avoid saying anything negative about your in-laws and your ex to your kids. I would hope your in-laws and ex would also avoid saying negative things about you but there is that possibility that they won’t hold their tongue. Maybe you should consider talking to your in-laws and making it clear that you plan on maintaining a relationship with them for your kids’ sake. Also, gently request that all parties involved not say negative things about each other in the presence of kids and that you would like to maintain open communication. If this is too uncomfortable for you, consider having a 3rd party or therapist involved as a mediator to negotiate the relationship. Everyone has a responsibility toward the children involved.

What are some of the myths around in-laws we might carry with us after a break-up that can add to frustration and family issues?

Interesting question! Some may believe that their in-laws are back-biting and that might interfere with how you approach your in-laws. When you have doubts about someone’s feelings towards you, it can affect your demeanor toward them. There’s no guarantee that they would be saying anything about you behind your back but if you go in with assumption, naturally you’ll act defensive. Another common myth is that in-laws will take their son’s or daughter’s side always and not yours. That may not be true. Again if you assume that your in-laws are “against” you, you may act defensive and create tension when there wasn’t any to begin with. I would recommend not asking your in-laws to ever take sides or even bringing up the faults in your ex. However, if your in-laws bring up the issues that led to the divorce or anything related, don’t hesitate to answer their questions or calm their concerns. Do it gently though. I realize many in-laws can be horrible and circumstances leading to the divorce can be even worse but for the benefit of the children involved, it’s important to maintain a cordial relationship. I would highly recommend talking to your ex about your desire to maintain a relationship with his or her family. You want him to be comfortable with your relationship with his family and you don’t want to put a strain on his relationship with his family. They may be his only source of support. Basically, communication is really important in this relationship. Avoid making assumptions. And do what’s the most beneficial for the kids as long as it doesn’t affect your emotional health.

 

You can follow Nadia on:

Twitter: @desiinlaws

FB: http://www.facebook.com/pages/South-Asian-In-Laws/160392800724716


©masalamommas and masalamommas.com, 2016-2017. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to masalamommas.com and Masalamommas online magazine with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.

(Visited 4,656 times, 1 visits today)



There are 6 comments

Add yours
  1. Sara

    Good points a positive educated approach that can foster a healthy relationship which is is a must for all children loved it , good job masalamommas

  2. Hana

    Interesting Article, but its very difficult to even want to keep any relations with ur ex and his family, when they been abusive towards you. Yes its important that my child doesn’t see any hostility, which is y its better we got a divorce, but I personally cannot even imagine ever wanting to keep any relations with my ex inlaws. I allow and enccourage my sons relation with them by taking him to go for his visits even when he doesn’t want to, and making him talk to his father on the phone, even when he is throwing the phone away, and not talking abt them at all in front of my son.

    • Anjum

      hi Hana
      completely onside with your comment. As I mentioned in the article, this topic has so many dimensions that we ‘re just taking our first look at this and leaving the forum open to more upcoming followup articles. In situations like yours the dynamic is certainly different and we hope to encourage dialog on this subject both on the site and in an online twitter chat coming up on April 4th 8pm EST with our hosts MySahana.com. hope you can join us and please do write to our contributor, Nadia Shah as well. she’s at southasianinlaws.com. thanks so much for your comment and shedding light on this area, it’s very important.

      Anjum

    • Nadia

      Hana, I totally respect and understand your decision to not want a relationship with your in-laws. Like Anjum mentioned, your situation has a different dynamic. You’re doing what’s best for you and your child’s emotional health and that’s what’s most important. And in fact, you are managing your relationship with them because you have the insight to know that your son will benefit by everyone being cordial, or at least you being cordial. You ARE very strong to come out of an abusive relationship and to handle your situation well.


Post a new comment

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: